Toiletsguide is audience-supported. When you buy through links on this site, we may earn an affiliate commission that we use for site maintenance. Learn more


Shower Shroom vs Tubshroom | Which One’s to Try?

shower shroom vs tubshroom
Written by Elizabeth Fincher
Last Update: August 10, 2023

Both ShowerShrooms and TubShrooms are great at catching dirty gunk while letting water flow without a hitch.

TubShrooms are smaller and need frequent cleaning. The intuitive design and material quality make TubShrooms a better choice for basins, sinks, and tubs.

On the other hand, ShowerShrooms do a pretty decent job themselves; especially if you use a metal one. They are purpose-built for showers and other drain systems.

What’s ShowerShroom?

I’m sure you have been annoyed by the drain of your shower getting clogged with hair and other unwanted materials at least once. Almost all of us have faced this nuisance multiple times.

A ShowerShroom can help you to solve this problem. It is a new-age drain protector that you can use to prevent drain blockage/clogging.

This handy protector ensures the free flow of water in your drain by trapping hair and any other large waste materials. It collects all those waste materials in a ring below its water holes.

You can easily remove all those waste materials by detaching the ring.

Why Showershrooms Are Great

1. Anti-clog drain protector

ShowerShrooms are stain, scratch, and dust resistant. These nifty drain protectors catch almost all the hair and other shower residues preventing your drains from clogging.

Nobody likes to call plumbers in their home every now and then. Plus, you can save a good amount of money you give away for plumbing just by using these over all your drains.

2. Looks great on the shower drain

ShowerShrooms usually come in as a 2-inch sized drain protector. You can use them in your shower, bathroom, or any other drain. There is also a variety of colors to choose from.

ShowerShrooms are usually made of rubber. The unique design helps them fit with almost any type of bathroom or shower while having a pleasant look.

3. Quick to clean with paper towels

It’s no use if your drain protector catches all the debris but makes it difficult to clean. Most ShowerShrooms are built in a way that makes the cleaning process effortless.

Just unplug the ShowerShroom, clean it with a piece of paper towel and you are good to go.

Showershroom Disadvantages

1. May clog the drain itself

ShowerShrooms may prevent your drains from clogging, but there are some limitations to that.

As ShowerShrooms are mostly made from rubber, there is a possibility that the ShowerShroom can become weak after extensive use and fall down the drain itself.

Who wants to call a plumber for something they did to get rid of their plumbing issues? Now that would be a gigantic pain.

What’s TubShroom?

Much like the ShowerShroom, the TubShroom is also a drain protector that you can use to prevent clogging. Being a bit smaller at around 1.5 inches, they are specially built for bathrooms.

TubShrooms can be used in almost any drain that runs vertically downwards.

There are a number of specially designed nets on their body that allow water to flow freely while trapping unwanted wastes.

TubShrooms also work great with animal hairs. They are eco-friendly and easy to clean. Due to better building material, TubShrooms are a bit costlier than ShowerShrooms.

Why Tubshrooms Are Great

1. Supports easy cleaning

TubShrooms are really easy to clean. TubShrooms come in snug-fit designs so they are easy to use in almost all types of drains.

The intuitive design collects all the waste hairs and other residues in the lower section of the device. Just like a ShowerShroom, you’ll also be able to clean a TubShroom effortlessly.

2. Saves money in the long run

TubShrooms require no complex installation process and prevent your drains from getting blocked. That way it can help you save money in the long run, especially the money you usually pay your plumbers for cleaning drains.

TubShrooms can also cut down the cost of using expensive and harmful chemicals that you use to clear your drain, which makes them an eco-friendly choice.

3. Safe for pets

As mentioned earlier, TubShrooms work great for both animal and human hairs. The neat design helps collect animal hairs and keep them neatly trapped.

Whether it’s shower time for you or your little friend, TubShrooms can catch all of your shredded hairs without your drains clogging up.

Just clean the device every once in a while and you’ll be good to go.

4. You can take bath with it

Most probably the biggest plus point of a TubShroom is that it can also be used in showers. It works so great that it’s advertised as “The Last Hair Strainer You’ll Ever Buy”.

Not only that, this nifty little device has been declared the winner of the 2018 KBB Product Innovator Award.

Tubshroom Disadvantages

1. It gets dirty

As TubShrooms collect almost all the waste from your shower/bathroom, it gets pretty dirty. Additionally, they may develop mold over their body after long use.

This might be true that TubShrooms are easy to clean. But even that becomes a hectic job when hair gets twisted around multiple tiny holes.

2. Needs frequent cleaning

TubShrooms collect almost all the debris they can get. That’s why they get clogged easily and start to slow down the flow of water.

Due to this, TubShrooms need frequent cleaning. If you have thick hair, you may need to clean it after each shower.

Shower Shroom vs Tubshroom: How Do They Differ?

Aspect Tubshroom Showershroom
Size 1.5” 2”
Weight 0.48 ounces 1.44 ounces
Material Silicone Rubber
Special Features Snug fit for drains Scratch-, dust-& rust-resistant
Price Around $15 Around $10
Type of resistance Rust-resistant and stain-resistant Rust resistance, stain-resistant, and scratch resistance
Diameter of drain 1.5 to 1.75 inches 2.4 inches

1. Construction

There is a wide variety of materials that are used to construct both ShowerShrooms and TubShrooms. The most widely used materials are plastic, steel, silicon, and aluminum.

However, plastic and silicon-made devices tend to develop mold and become flimsy after long use.

TubShrooms have better construction than ShowerShrooms. ShowerShrooms have the potential of clogging the drain itself.

2. Cost

They both are quite inexpensive but due to the better design and material used, TubShroom is a little more expensive.

TubShrooms last longer and provide better support than ShowerShrooms. That is why TubShrooms are worth the extra penny. You can find both for under $15.

3. Design

If you are looking for a satisfactory level of performance, both ShowerShrooms and TubShrooms are good choices. They allow the water to flow seamlessly while catching all the junk.

However, if you are searching for a smarter design that will collect all the debris and allow the water to flow freely, the TubShroomstriumphs here.

4. Installation

This is a tough battle. ShowerShrooms can compete against TubShrooms on equal ground. The installation process of ShowerShrooms and TubShrooms are similar.

ShowerShrooms have a crossbar-like arm structure to secure their position over your drain grate.

We have no winner here since both of them are plug-and-play devices.

5. Cleaning

Here ShowerShrooms secure the lead. Despite the fact that TubShrooms are easy to clean, ShowerShrooms can hold much more hair and need cleaning once or twice every month.

On the other hand, TubShrooms require much more frequent cleaning. If you don’t have a problem with that, you’ll be more than satisfied with a TubShroom.

About the author

Elizabeth Fincher

Elizabeth started her career as an interior design artist at a multinational interior design farm. She completed her masters degree from the University of North Texas back in 2010. She was also a Spelling Bee runner-up when she was 14. She took interest in bathroom interior designing after joining her first job. Later she started her own firm as an independent artist. She’s been one of the founding members of Toiletsguide. She examines the design and ergonomics of the units we review and directs the interior decoration team of our in-house research facility. Elizabeth plays piano masterfully and always finds time to entertain us in between our busy schedules.

Leave a Comment