For many, a macerator toilet may sound complicated and may leave us baffled and wondering what this strange name means. But in situations when a gravity drain is not possible in a bathroom, an upflush toilet appears as a savior. It has a motorized turbine rotation system that grinds solid human waste into a slurry form, which is easier to move out through the drain pipe. The macerator then pumps clean sealing water in the seating bowl.
It's a technologically advanced waste management system that can handle heavy load and if maintained properly should deliver smooth operation for years. Its reliability makes it a common choice for public restrooms, but it can perform magic at the household washrooms too. The only problem is that there are just so many different models on the market, making it hard for an ordinary buyer to find the best upflush toilet that is superbly effective and stylish at the same time.
Don’t worry. We are here to help you learn more about them so you detect the black horses with ease.
Why you should trust us
Here at ToiletsGuide we seek the most advanced and sophisticated bathroom fixtures and fittings that would satisfy your aesthetic and pragmatic needs, yet would hardly break the bank. With that mission, our team members - a group of professional plumbing engineers, interior designers, and artists - have been relentlessly working hard to carry out extensive market research on exclusive bathroom fixtures and fittings. Our research-backed findings help us write the most comprehensive and elaborate product reviews and how-to blogs that readers find unbiased and authentic.
We make sure that our recommendations are bias-free and objective by disconnecting ourselves from every brand or manufacturer. We carry out field-tests on our reviewed items for getting a better understanding of how they really perform. We expect our readers properly utilize our database (don't forget to go through the fact-sheet attached below) before coming to a final decision.
How did we pick these products?
Our research protocol contained several stages to make the process as much reliable as we could. We started off with a 30-hour vehement online research to find 25 upflush toilet models with the highest number of ratings and positive user reviews and feedback.
After shortlisting 25 models from hundreds of different choices we wanted to use them in real-life situations to have a better understanding of how they actually performed, as well as if the paperwork coming with them spoke the truth. Our team members along with a group of volunteers tested each of the listed items for a period of over 2 weeks. That helped us gain enough data to work with. Then, based on their performances, water efficiencies, ergonomics, designs, pricing, building materials, bowl capacities, and technical abilities this top 8 list was made.
However, the quest didn't end there. We had to listen to the top industry experts and renowned plumbing engineers before we finally ranked those models. Their valuable insights helped us categorize the products based on their special features. That's how we drafted the ultimate list of 8 top upflush toilets.
Our Top 8 Best Macerator Toilet List
We categorized our top picks based on the type they belong to. Some of these products are one-piece while others are two-piece. Some have low price points while others fall in the mid-range. We ranked our models according to their basic factors like flush valve size, design and look, bowl type, etc.
The aim of this review was to help you find what you needed to know before making an informed buying decision. Still wondering what is the best upflush toilet? Here we go!
Why use an upflush toilet
So why should you go for a flush up toilet and what makes it different from the standard fixtures? First, it has a good working mechanism that doesn't require the gravitational pull force like the standard models. In this sewage treatment, a chopper pump reduces the solid human wastes to small pieces by using a grinding or blending mechanism.
The macerator, which is the discharge system, has a rotating blade that shreds and grinds solid human waste into a semi-liquid state. It then mixes the waste with flushing water turning it into a fine slurry that can easily move up the narrow pipe.
The most common parts in any of these models are the multi-diameter, a sleeve, a toilet fill valve, and a rotating blade. These four are connected on the inside of the pump each playing a significant role.
The multi-diameter is an outlet that swivels waste 360o. A valve makes it easier to clean, leaving no waste, a sleeve is responsible for fitting the horizontal outlet and a rotating blade for grinding the solid waste.
Outside connections are also needed for the basement set-ups. Connect the macerator pump to the plug of the horizontal outlet. Make sure to connect the toilet tank to a water supply. Next, connect the pump to a small diameter discharge pipe to an electricity supply.
So what are the benefits of macerating technology? Let's find out.
You can have a remote toilet in any place of your home without the need to break any concrete. The good thing is that you can modernize your own toilet without breaking the floor.
The toilet has a low consumption of water since the maceration process makes it easier to dispose of waste. But you must install an upflush toilet venting system so sewer gases, toilet smells, and methane can be exhausted out from your building.
Easy to install
With an up flush toilet, you don’t have to worry about extra plumbing costs. You can even fix it yourself as they are easy to install. So there’s no need of getting a plumber to do so.
You'd always want your toilet system to be an easy-to-clean and easy-to-maintain type. You will notice that the up flush models have two components that play a big role in proper functioning: macerator and the pump. The two are enclosed since you cannot face problems with them unless you end up abusing them.
Upflush toilets - Buying guide
There are several things to look at when it comes to choosing an upflow toilet system. We can’t say for sure that there is only one best macerating toilet system on the market. That’s because different toilets have different flushing systems. Some have unique features and design while others have exceptional functionality. You will have to choose one that suits you the most.
However, you need to get familiar with some of the key terms. Let’s get started.
1. Design & look
Toilets come in different shapes and designs, giving you several options to choose from. A good one should complement its surroundings. Macerating toilets come in two designs - one-piece, and two-piece. The one-piece is also called the single piece, offers a more refined look and has the tank and the bowl fused together. This makes it easier to clean, install and minimize the risk of leakage.
The two-piece model is the most popular one. It comes with the bowl separate from the tank. The good thing about this is that you can independently replace the bowl or the tank. It is also budget-friendly.
There is also another recent design called the wall-mounted toilet. It is installed and supported by the wall. Being one of the most expensive designs, it fits smaller bathrooms and for people with mobility issues. The advantages of using a wall-mounted one are they are quieter, adjustable, and help keep the floor clean.
2. Bowl shape
The shape of the bowl seat determines the comfort you’ll have. There are two types of bowls, around and an elongated bowl. Elongated bowls offer maximum comfort due to its wider seating space but occupy a larger area. Round bowls, on the other hand, are better for narrower spaces.
3. Gallons per flush (GPF)
The GPF of your toilet will determine the consumption of water in your household. And since you may want to save on your water bills and at the same time reduce your carbon footprint, then a 1.6GPF is enough. Nonetheless, macerating models considered economical when it comes to water usage. Average water used for dual flush system is not more than 1.6 GPF. Advanced models keep it within 1.28 GPF.
4. Noise level
Another thing you need to take into consideration is the noise level, especially if you have kids in the house. Some upflush toilets are designed to have a quiet flush while others flush loudly.
An additional thing about the noise level you need to look at is the lid. Some are silent-closure lids while some are not. The good thing about silent lids is that you don’t have to be startled while it falls on the bowl. So it’s really important to decide what you want.
5. Maximum depth of operation
A macerating toilet system functions differently from the other standard models of toilets. That’s why you need to take a look at how the sewer lines and the drain pipes are placed. Ideally, these pipes have to be elevated so that the disposal can be flushed upwards.
So if you are planning to set it up in the basement, it is recommended to get an extra distance to get the maximum support depth.
6. Macerating pump
Take a look at the voltage, amperage, and horsepower among other listed specifications to determine the efficiency of the macerating pump. Also, consider the macerator seal too, as this will determine its durability. You can go for a stainless steel pump to get the most out of it.
Another thing, since the upflush toilet pump houses the blades, you should embrace the material that is more efficient and robust.
7. Flush valve size
The power of a single flush is influenced by the size of the valve. A large valve can clear all the contents in the bowl with just one flush.
8. Weight & dimensions
Some of the macerator models weigh 17 kg, while others can be more or less than that. The weight determines the ease of installation, especially if you prefer doing it yourself. The single-piece models tend to be heavier than the two-piece since it comes as a whole unit intact.
Don't forget to look at the dimensions of your commode and the size of where you want to place it. The standard height of a one-piece model is 21 to 30 inches with 14 to 16 inches from the floor to the bowl. The width rarely exceeds 20 inches.
A two-piece height ranges of 26 to 32 inches and the width is the same as that of a one-piece.
9. Ease of installation
The installation process is easy, so there is no need to hire a plumber. Nonetheless, this will also depend on your skills. Make sure there is a dependable supply of water and electricity. If you are a fanatic handyman and have expertise in bathroom renovations, you will be able to install the toilet in no time. But if not you will have to do it in a couple of hours.
Other than that, just connect the spigot situated horizontally to the pump or the macerator. Then connect the tank to the water supply. Install the small diameter discharge pipe and lastly connect the pump or the macerator to the power supply.
10. Price & warranty
How much do you intend to spend on a flush up toilet? And does it come with a good warranty? These are some of the questions you need to ask yourself. Cheap upflush toilets might not serve your purpose though there are some cheap models available on the market. The basic models cost $100 to $250. They are the most budget-friendly and will do the job well plus consume less water.
The mid-range products cost within a range of $250 to $500. These do a little more than the first ones. You can even get a dual flush model with that price.
Lastly, the expensive ones cost more than $500. Expect certain features like bidet functions, better flushing technologies like siphonic systems and warming seats. Designs with this price are more revolutionized, compact, and streamlines. The smartest models can go all the way up to $1,000.
Don’t forget to look at the warranty especially for the two-piece. Standard models come with a more than 5-year warranty. Others come with a year or two-year warranty. For the two-piece, the warranty may vary for different parts.
Knowing how to maintain these toilets should enhance their overall hygiene and longevity. We’ve listed all the tips below that will help keep your toilets in a good state.
- Clean your up flushing toilet systems regularly
- To clean, first, turn off the power to the macerator. Pour down your cleaner into the bowl and make sure that it is not highly abrasive. Allow it to stay for a few hours and use a soft bristle brush to scrub the bowl. Turn on the power and flush
- You can also use vinegar and baking soda for cleaning. Sprinkle one cup of baking soda into the bowl and then one cup of the vinegar. Let it sit for about 30 minutes with the lid closed. Lift the bowl and then using a soft bristle brush scrub the toilet and then flush. Use this mixture at least once a week
- Don’t dispose of certain items by flushing down e.g. sanitary pads, diaper and the likes which will clog the system
- Use a high-quality upflush sewage pump kit if you need to replace the old one
- Avoid using cleaning products that are not from the manufacturer
As seen above, all macerators work in the same way. A few need three connections while most of them are good with four. Our recommended models are very close in quality and performance. All are highly dependable solutions for your waste management. They are safe and comfy as much as they flaunt futuristic design language.
We’ve discussed everything you need to know about the best upflush toilet systems. Our explanations are detailed and analytical in order to give you the idea of what you are looking for.
In our up flush toilet reviews, Saniflo Saniplus is our top choice for the level of efficiency, aesthetics, and ergonomics it offers. Sanibest Pro, on the other hand, beats all the toilets due to its heavy-duty performance in public places. There are some Saniflo alternative models, but nothing is as good as a Saniflo toilet when it's about upflush toilet.
No model from renowned brands like Star Water Systems, Zoeller, and Kohler made it to our final list since we followed a strict selection protocol. These products were good but not good enough to earn a place on our top 8 list.
As you can see, there is no panacea we talked about, instead, we've tried to come up with ideal commode solutions in different categories. Now, it's all up to you to choose which one suits you the most.